Great day Lykkers! I don't think I've ever been more loyal to a makeup product than I am to my setting spray. After spending time blending everything together, the last thing I want is for my makeup to fade halfway through the day.

I've tested quite a few over the years, but these two are the ones everyone seems to compare. So...which one do I actually reach for?

1. ONE/SIZE On 'Til Dawn Mattifying Waterproof Setting Spray

If you've been following my makeup favorites for a while, this one probably isn't a surprise. I genuinely can't imagine doing my makeup without it anymore. Once I finish my look, a few sprays are all I need, and everything stays exactly where I want it. I've worn it through long days, hot weather, and busy events, and it never lets me down. It keeps my makeup looking fresh for hours without making it feel heavy. You can probably tell how much I love it because I ended up buying the jumbo bottle—and trust me, it gets plenty of use.

2. L'Oréal Infallible 3-Second Setting Mist

I wasn't expecting this one to impress me as much as it did, but it really surprised me. Considering the price, it performs incredibly well and does a great job helping my makeup last throughout the day. The biggest reason people compare it to ONE/SIZE is easy to understand. It delivers a very similar result for much less money, making it a great option if you're shopping on a budget or simply don't want to splurge.

Even though I still reach for ONE/SIZE most often, I have to give credit where it's due. L'Oréal created an impressive alternative that delivers great performance without the higher price tag. If I'm getting ready for a special occasion or know I'll be wearing makeup all day, I'm still grabbing my ONE/SIZE bottle without thinking twice. But for everyday makeup, the L'Oréal spray is an easy recommendation and one I'd happily use again.